Randy

Profile

Username:
solitaire
Name:
Randy
Location:
Rossville, IN
Birthday:
03/24
Status:
Single
Job / Career:
Human Resources

Stats

Post Reads:
168,776
Posts:
705
Photos:
16
Last Online:
> 30 days ago
View All »

My Friends

17 hours ago
16 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago

Subscribe

Par For The Course

Religion > Editorial Critique
 

Editorial Critique

I read recently Bill Nye's response to the recent Gallup Poll results regarding evolution beliefs. I'm tempted to write a "tongue in cheek" letter to the editor of our local newspaper (Laf. IN). In raw form, here it is. Tell me what you think, criticisms welcomed.

Dear Editor,

Bill Nye isn't the only "science guy" that is upset over the recent Gallup Poll's survey that indicates 47% of United States adults reject evolution. This percentage has not changed in 30 years. Nye blames parents for the continuation of the propagation of the God creation myth.

I disagree. The blame is on me. As a former science teacher, which included biology, I, and many others, evidently failed in convincing our youth that evolution is a scientific fact. Since virtually all high school students take biology and supposedly learned the concepts of evolution, where did we go wrong? Were students asleep? Is the subject that boring?

Only 15% (one in seven!) of adult Americans accept evolution as a natural biological process. Ignore all the fossil and genetic evidence. Never mind the recent Hubble telescope discoveries showing the universe to be over 13 billion years old. If the Bible implies the earth's age to be no more than ten thousand years old with Adam and Eve created at that time, then that's "proof" enough.

We can play the blame game all we want. Education has failed to sway the populace. Church dogma continues to trump science.

Randall Smith

posted on Sept 26, 2012 5:50 AM ()

Comments:

I think it's great. And it will make those 47% mad. I agree with the myth part, although maybe not the right word... urban legend, brain washing, fairytale??
comment by crazylife on Sept 26, 2012 8:51 PM ()
I can't think of a better substitute for myth. It is what it is. And I meant it as a dig, although the truth doesn't faze the faithful. Is everything well with you?
reply by solitaire on Sept 27, 2012 5:14 AM ()
Funny about polls and statistics. My feeling is that it doesn't matter how many people don't believe in something so long as that something is fact. They are simply wrong. That's my feeling. A poll or a statistic like that does not change the fact.
comment by jondude on Sept 26, 2012 6:54 PM ()
True, but we're a society that loves to know how we individuals fit in. Surveys serve a purpose, like what the trends are.
reply by solitaire on Sept 27, 2012 5:11 AM ()
I am a firm believer in evolution AND a Christian. God can use evolution to create the universe as easily as a magical, "poof, here is the universe." The theory of evolution does not preclude God. Your letter- must you insult everyone who believes in God in order to make your point? (The God creation 'MYTH'??) Can you not refer to it as a 'version' or 'theory'? As soon as you insult everyone who believes in God, they shut off and tune you out. You lose credibility. I read your post and these replies and I wonder why atheists find it necessary to insult theists in order to reject their beliefs. Oh well...Love you anyway.
comment by dragonflyby on Sept 26, 2012 9:02 AM ()
I'm not sure we (I) intend to insult. "Myth", for example, is the correct word. The Bible's creation story comes directly from the Mithra predecessors. It's hardly a theory. What we nonbelievers say is already rejected or tuned out. 'Twas ever thus. You belong to the 35% group, by the way. And I'm glad you haven't rejected me!
reply by solitaire on Sept 27, 2012 5:07 AM ()
It's hard to blame the educational system, or educators, when even some people earning advanced degrees have swum in the sea of knowledge and avoided getting wet. Cough--RonPaul!-- Cough!

And how about farmers -- are they largely creationists or something? Is that why they continue to enable the evolution of antibiotic-resistant superbugs by feeding livestock regular doses of antibiotics before the animals are even sick -- because they never accepted the science in the first place?
comment by drmaus on Sept 26, 2012 8:56 AM ()
Good points. Oh, the hypocrisy of "believers". I'll bet Mitt is a creationist. Obama?
reply by solitaire on Sept 27, 2012 4:59 AM ()
I'm guessing the 47% that rejects evolution is not the same as Romney's now infamous 47%. My reaction: I'm flabbergasted. Talk about how dumbed-down the populace has become (hey, maybe it IS the fault of you teachers). Your response is good, tho' I would make it more strongly worded, more aghast at what is happening, more disgusted with the creeping imbecility of anyone stupid enough to not accept the truth of evolution of biblical nonsense.
comment by steve on Sept 26, 2012 7:41 AM ()
Oh how I want to say "You ignorant, pathetic dumb asses...". I went at it in a roundabout way. I don't want to alienate the few friends and neighbors I have. My house is flammable.
reply by solitaire on Sept 27, 2012 4:55 AM ()
That should read: "...over biblical nonsense."
reply by steve on Sept 26, 2012 7:43 AM ()
I don't think human intelligence can begin to grasp the origins of our universe/parallel universes and where it all began. It's like asking ants what they think of the big people that go around stomping on them. I think evolution is its own explanation -- what can happen will or may happen. As for teachers alone being responsible for the lack of understanding, I think you cannot ignore the pressure of family ignorance and the emotional need to believe in a big daddy in the sky and ignore all the horrific things that Big Daddy allows and, you know, that "mysterious ways" thing that I think is self-serving because the clergy and the church get big bucks for selling this stuff. And the ones who are honest and sincere and believe in equality are in the minority. Those polled were, no doubt, religious. Religion teaches creationism. Parents buy that and teach it to their children. By the time the kids get to a grade where science is taught, they are already programmed. You'd have to use the donkey approach. First, hit them over the head with a crowbar to get their attention and then speak. Those children who by virtue of an innate intelligence choose their own questions, are in the minority. Mostly teachers have to undo those beliefs taught in the home that are at odds with science. That is an an uphill battle. Furthermore, many teachers are religious. We'll never solve this one except to maintain separation of church and state and vote against any religion overtaking our political process.
comment by tealstar on Sept 26, 2012 7:38 AM ()
I was one of those kids who asked questions even while being indoctrinated by the nuns. The turning point came when a nun answered a question with, "we can never know". Maybe we won't figure it out that day, but that's no excuse not to search. So I did: elsewhere.
reply by jjoohhnn on Sept 27, 2012 6:20 AM ()
Yup. No doubt kids are brainwashed from an early age. Sorta like republicans. I wanted to say "ignorance is bliss" in the letter, but thought better of it.
reply by solitaire on Sept 27, 2012 4:52 AM ()
What still baffles me is how anybody can accept that some sort of super-consciousness with some degree of intelligence (which I question) can pop out of nothing and create everything, but the notion that one species can mutate into a new form is too farfetched.

I always like to speculate on creation: "Let's see," said the god, "how can I give them energy to survive?" Good question, god! "I know, I'll have them eat each other!" Yup, very godly indeed.
comment by jjoohhnn on Sept 26, 2012 6:55 AM ()
Hurray for a fellow 15 percenter! You're so right.
reply by solitaire on Sept 27, 2012 4:49 AM ()
OMG! Love the eat each other part!
reply by crazylife on Sept 26, 2012 8:47 PM ()
I think it's well said.
comment by kristilyn3 on Sept 26, 2012 6:47 AM ()
Thanks. I'm still considering sending it in.
reply by solitaire on Sept 27, 2012 4:46 AM ()

Comment on this article   


705 articles found   [ Previous Article ]  [ Next Article ]  [ First ]  [ Last ]