I haven't voted my 25 times as of today, but I'm compiling my All-Stars list for the American League. I have voted only a couple times because it is boring to keep clicking on the same names.
Catcher: Mauer (Twins)
Pitcher, even though we don't get to vote for a pitcher: Cliff Lee (Indians. He's 10-1 and Sabbathia is still in the losing column.)
1st Base: Kevin Youklis (Red Sox)
2nd Base: Polanco?
Shortstop: Izturis (Angels)
3rd Base: Casey Blake (Indians) but maybe Mike Lowell (Red Sox)
Outfielders: Grady Sizemore, Germaine Dye (White Sox) and Manny Ramirez (Red Sox... only because it wouldn't be an All-Star game without Mannyball)
DH: Pappy Ortiz (Red Sox - whatever_)
I never cast votes for the National League because I only get to watch those teams during interleague play.