Laura

Profile

Username:
troutbend
Name:
Laura
Location:
Estes Park, CO
Birthday:
08/01
Status:
Married
Job / Career:
Hotel - Hospitality

Stats

Post Reads:
482,997
Posts:
1942
Photos:
15
Last Online:
> 30 days ago
View All »

My Friends

10 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago

Subscribe

This Oughta Be Good

Health & Fitness > The Nun Study
 

The Nun Study

Today I was listening to a discussion on NPR (National Public Radio) about detecting Alzheimer's Disease.

Agatha Christie And Nuns Tell A Tale Of Alzheimer's

"Ian Lancashire, an English professor at the University of Toronto, has spent much of his career trying to see past the words on the page and into the psyche of the author. He makes concordances of different texts; basically, an alphabetical list of all the words and the contexts in which they appear in a text. This is a tradition that dates back to medieval monks, who would make concordances of the Bible in the hopes of seeing the mind of God.

Lancashire has somewhat more modest goals. He studies the works of authors such as Chaucer, Shakespeare and Milton. (Among other things, he discovered that Milton never used the word "because" in any of his works. Why? Who knows.) But in the mid '90s, Lancashire decided he wanted to focus on a more modern — and less "literary" — author. So he turned to one of the most published authors in the world: Agatha Christie."



Agatha Christie wrote 80 novels. By running the concordance Lancashire noticed that starting with novel number 70 ("Elephants Can Remember") her vocabulary decreased by 20%, and it wasn't nearly as well written as her earlier novels. From this it has been concluded that she had Alzheimer's Disease.

We can never know for sure if Christie actually had Alzheimer's. But a separate study out of the University of Minnesota lends support to the idea that there might be signs in our writing of Alzheimer's disease. And those signs might be there very early on.

The so-called "Nun Study" was started by David Snowdon at the University of Minnesota in 1990 (although the study participants are not officially nuns, they're sisters). Snowdon wanted to look at aging over time, and decided to focus on sisters because they all had fairly similar histories and backgrounds. Most of them joined the School Sisters of Notre Dame congregation when they were 18, and all had abstained from smoking or drinking. So Snowdon signed up 678 sisters, all over the age of 75, from the order. All of the sisters agreed to donate a small part of their brains to the study after they died.

Researchers would visit once a year to administer memory tests, and it was during one of these visits that Snowdon made a fortuitous discovery: He was told of a collection of biographies that the sisters were required to write upon entering the order, in many cases more than 50 years before the study started. "It was a major, major find," says Serguei Pakhomov, a current researcher with the study.Snowdon and his team evaluated the essays based on grammatical complexity and idea density – the average number of discrete ideas contained in every 10 written words.

Here's an example of a sentence packed with ideas, from the one of the sister's diaries:

"It was about a half hour before midnight between February 28 and 29 of the leap year 1912 when I began to live, and to die, as the third child of my mother, whose maiden name is Hilda Hoffman, and my father, Otto Schmidt..."

And here's an example of less idea-rich sentence:

"I was born in Eau Claire, Wisconsin on May 24, 1913, and was baptized in St. James Church..."



Snowdon discovered that sisters who scored poorly on these two measures — like the second example — were much more likely to develop dementia. Sisters within the lower third of the sample with respect to idea density, for example, were 60 times more likely to develop Alzheimer's than a sister in the upper third. In fact, using the essays, the researchers could predict with 92 percent accuracy whether the brain of a particular sister, investigated after their death, would contain the plaques and lesions in the brain that are associated with Alzheimer's Disease.

Kelvin Lim, the current director of the "Nun Study," cautions that their finding is merely an association and doesn't mean that simple writing causes dementia later in life. And while other studies suggest that the initial stages of Alzheimer's may appear very early, it is still unclear whether writing could be used as a reliable early warning sign."

Does this make you want to dig out something you wrote years ago and compare it to what you wrote yesterday?

Sister Nicolette, one of the nuns in the study, died at age 102.

posted on Oct 17, 2010 8:48 PM ()

Comments:

Fascinating post, Laura. I read this post after finishing my daily crossword puzzle, which I enjoy doing because it perks up my thinking and vocabulary. I usually learn a new word or two each time, which hopefully means I'm gaining something. As a poet and writer, words are my favorite brain food.
comment by marta on Oct 23, 2010 12:19 PM ()
I saw it, too, a couple times, on PBS. Great fun! Will does a fun segment on NPR Sunday mornings, too.
reply by marta on Oct 25, 2010 10:07 PM ()
There is a fascinating DVD called "Wordplay" about Will Shortz, the crossword editor for the NY Times, how crossword puzzles are designed, and an annual contest for crossword puzzlers. I got it from Netflix.
reply by troutbend on Oct 25, 2010 1:29 PM ()
I agree with elderjane, isolation whether it is in a young person or, an older person is bound to have an effect on ones mind (prisoners in jail have isolation as a punishment). With the dawning of 'the computer', perhaps it helps make a person less, alone - blogging, for an example, is a great way to communicate with the outside world (world, being the operative word). However, not every older person, has grasped the Internet or, has had someone to help them to.
I think this was an extremely interesting article Laura
comment by febreze on Oct 20, 2010 9:17 AM ()
At home, I listen to BBC 7 via the Internet. I like the dramatization of classic novels and some of the comedians.
reply by troutbend on Oct 22, 2010 11:45 AM ()
This is an ever present fear in the older population. From personal
observation, I can say that isolating oneself is definitely a symptom.
Perhaps it could be a factor instead of a symptom. We just don't know
enough about how the human brain works. I find it fascinating.
comment by elderjane on Oct 20, 2010 5:23 AM ()
Mr. Tbend is on the way here today. I am watching the road condition cameras in the mountains hoping I would see his car go by. Wouldn't that be funny.
reply by troutbend on Oct 22, 2010 11:49 AM ()
Interesting, thanks for posting this. And I bet they wrote those biographies in cursive. Today that is a lost art.
comment by anacoana on Oct 19, 2010 5:02 PM ()
Ms. Laura, not remembering going from one room to another merely means you were temporarily focused on something else. When really concentrating on a nasty problem, I have walked city blocks and looked up to find myself in a strange neighborhood. Wouldn't worry about it. It's a trance state.
comment by tealstar on Oct 19, 2010 7:53 AM ()
Oh, I'm not to that stage yet, however I will admit to once in while walking in a room and forgetting what I went in there for. It doesn't bother me overly much because I know a lot of us experience that.
reply by troutbend on Oct 19, 2010 9:33 AM ()
If my poor writing--past and present--is any indication, I'm a prime candidate for Alzy. At least knowing that the disease is more prevalent in women than men, reassures me that my chances are improved for evasion.
comment by solitaire on Oct 19, 2010 5:27 AM ()
I think you're going to live forever and stay sharp as a tack.
reply by troutbend on Oct 19, 2010 9:34 AM ()
Oh, I'd be scared to look at my old stuff!This was truly fascinating.
comment by juliansmom on Oct 18, 2010 6:21 AM ()
It was so interesting to hear about it on the radio while I was driving, because I tuned in a little late, so didn't know what it was about - first they're talking about Agatha Christie, and the next thing we're hearing about writing that is rich in ideation and nuns.
reply by troutbend on Oct 18, 2010 7:37 PM ()
In poring over old papers, some from my so-called working life writing, I am sometimes impressed with what I wrote years ago and wonder how I did it. On the other hand, my short-term memory still works. I can remember, not, perhaps where I put my glasses, but the page number I was on when I put the book down as I prepared for sleep.
comment by tealstar on Oct 18, 2010 5:27 AM ()
It's so hard to know how much absent-mindedness is normal. The day I find myself in another room and don't remember getting there is when I'll start worrying.
reply by troutbend on Oct 18, 2010 7:40 PM ()

Comment on this article   


1,942 articles found   [ Previous Article ]  [ Next Article ]  [ First ]  [ Last ]