Susil

Profile

Username:
susil
Name:
Susil
Location:
Carthage, MS
Birthday:
01/05
Status:
Single
Job / Career:
Other

Stats

Post Reads:
126,660
Posts:
759
Photos:
4
Last Online:
> 30 days ago

My Friends

21 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago

Subscribe

News From Mississippi

Life & Events > Picking at Scabs
 

Picking at Scabs

I heard a female psychologist on NPR saying that she tells anyone (I assume her clients) who was traumatized by the events of 9/11 that if they've ever seen the footage of the first tower collapsing and the plane striking the second tower, they should not ever watch it again and avoid the restrospectives being televised today. "They need to avoid getting sucked into watching it so they can get over it and go on with their life."
What a bunch of crock. What bull. The psychologist sounded a teeny bit hysterical and in need of psychology herself.

Here is a fundamental trait of human behavior: Human beings see some extraordinary catastropic event like the bombing of Pearl Harbor, the destruction of the Towers, the assasination of JFK, etc. and they have a need to talk about it, to see it again, to try to understand it and try to explain it.
Humans are natural rubberneckers period, because we are curious beings. When people see an accident, or some event sudden and terrible, they are drawn to look at it, to take in and assimilate it into rationality.

When the earliest humans encountered some distrastrous event-maybe their hunters being pushed off a cliff by a mastodon, or overwhelmed by sudden attack by enemies, etc., surely they would sit around their fires for generations and recall that time, and speak of it and re-enact it in their lore.
One day, as one generation passes into another, as one tragedy follows another, all the people who were alive at the time of the catastrophy die off and it becomes fodder for history books, and the rawness and acuteness of it fades.

I'd like to say to that psychologist that remembering and talking of horrible events is a natural human thing, it is not as she intimated, that it is like picking at scabs so that the soreness of it never gets well. You can't scab over emotion and feelings; in time, all things heal and there might be a scar, but that is the natural progression of things.

I didn't know a soul who died in the Towers or in the highjacked planes, but I watched some of the restrospectives today and felt such sorrow for those who died in such terrible circumstances, and teared up thinking of the waste of all those lives.
September 11, 2001/September 11, 2011

susil

PS One last thing--if I'm ever in a skyscraper that's on fire, I don't care if the police or firemen say stay put help is coming, I'm gonna get the hell out of there.



posted on Sept 11, 2011 4:58 PM ()

Comments:

I tend to side with the psychologist. The images are forever burned into
my brain. There is no way to change a thing. I feel the same about the
Oklahoma City bombing. It was a needless tragedy but I don't re-visit
horror and the only time I go to the memorial is when someone from out of
state wants to see it. We live in the Now and I only relive the happy
memories.
comment by elderjane on Sept 13, 2011 6:05 AM ()
Hi jeri; Thank God for optimist!
reply by susil on Sept 16, 2011 3:40 PM ()
this will die out,just like Pearl Harbor when we were attacked.
Lot of people have forgotten about this.
comment by fredo on Sept 12, 2011 10:28 AM ()
Hi fredo; That's right.
I was watching the Jackie tapes hosted by Diane Sawyer and realize two generations have passed since that time and now the acuteness of that is just a footnote in history.
reply by susil on Sept 16, 2011 3:44 PM ()
I recorded those shows yesterday, but may delete them without watching. The first few years after it happened, I watched as many retrospectives as I could. Somehow, watching the stories about survival and rescue feels like something I need to do, as if there is an answer in there somewhere. Some of this is because 7 months later my dad died when his small plane collided with a power plant in Texas. To this day there are unanswered questions, and that was a tiny incident compared to the 9-11 tragedy. Having gone through all it took to settle his estate with the complications of the sudden death and not being able to get right up to the accident site, I can almost imagine what the surviving families have had to deal with.
comment by troutbend on Sept 12, 2011 10:17 AM ()
Fog and disorientation. He was talking to the airport, and got permission to come to a lower altitude, below the clouds, and just happened to be right on top of the power plant. He flew between the two smoke stacks marked with strobe lights, and it's possible he though that was the runway.
reply by troutbend on Sept 16, 2011 7:19 PM ()
I watched several hours of the retrospectives, out of respect and empathy for those who suffered through it.
PS I assume no reason was found why your dad's plane crashed?
reply by susil on Sept 16, 2011 3:48 PM ()
I wallowed in it when it happened, I could see the towers from the roof of my loft, although by then I was living in Queens. I cried for days. I prefer not to re-live it. For those to whom it is new, I recommend the viewing. Not re-discussing it is not going to make me forget it and become complacent. When I hear WWII names -- Tarawa, Iwo Jima, Saipan, Wake Island, Guadalcanal, I still get teary. When I hear Roosevelt's voice, I get teary. I am not one of those who has to be reminded.
comment by tealstar on Sept 12, 2011 9:59 AM ()
Hi teal; Not reminded, but watched out of respect for the dead and the living who experienced it.
reply by susil on Sept 16, 2011 3:51 PM ()
They televised it so many times! The planes smacking the towers and the smoke and the collapses. I refused to watch it. I have a theory that the desire to watch that over and over again is akin to why some people watch auto racing - to catch the wrecks and collisions. As for me, I have no desire to dwell on the horror that killed so many innocents, but I choose instead to go on.
comment by jondude on Sept 12, 2011 5:35 AM ()
Hi jon; y'all don't understand me. I watched not for the "car wrecks and collisions." Of course everyone has to go on and go forward--what's the alternative? How does that saying go? Something about complacency, like "If you don't remember history you are doomed to repeat it."
It's a show of respect to watch at least a little of it every year, lest we become complacent by shoving unpleasant things from our minds.
reply by susil on Sept 16, 2011 3:57 PM ()
Good post Sue, as always. I don't understand JJ's comment.
comment by larryb on Sept 11, 2011 5:45 PM ()
Larry, when I first came to read the post there was only one line that said: "text to follow".
reply by jjoohhnn on Sept 11, 2011 6:22 PM ()
Thanks larry, hope you are well. I've enjoyed this cool dry spell so so much!
reply by susil on Sept 11, 2011 5:57 PM ()
BTW, nice break in the weather
reply by larryb on Sept 11, 2011 5:47 PM ()
You mean your too busy picking?
comment by jjoohhnn on Sept 11, 2011 5:29 PM ()
jj I tell you why I do that--this frickin old computer cuts me off about halfway thru a blog, so I post a blog reading text to follow, then go back in to write--it rarely kicks me off when I'm writing on the "edit" form.
reply by susil on Sept 11, 2011 6:44 PM ()
I was here before the text.
reply by jjoohhnn on Sept 11, 2011 6:20 PM ()
Wha???
reply by susil on Sept 11, 2011 5:36 PM ()

Comment on this article   


759 articles found   [ Previous Article ]  [ Next Article ]  [ First ]  [ Last ]