Laura

Profile

Username:
troutbend
Name:
Laura
Location:
Estes Park, CO
Birthday:
08/01
Status:
Married
Job / Career:
Hotel - Hospitality

Stats

Post Reads:
442,503
Posts:
1942
Photos:
15
Last Online:
> 30 days ago
View All »

My Friends

3 hours ago
5 days ago
21 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago
> 30 days ago

Subscribe

This Oughta Be Good

Entertainment > I Present My Case
 

I Present My Case

I knew someone who years ago was approached to be on The Peoples Court. He'd sold a bread maker to a woman at a garage sale, and even though it was sold 'as is' she decided it didn't work like she'd anticipated so sued him in small claims court for the $25 she paid for it plus several hundreds more for emotional distress. Apparently those TV shows have scouts who monitor court filings around the country looking for unusual cases and thought they could make this into an entertaining segment. They invited this guy to fly to New York City and present his side of the story to Judge Wapner. He wasn't interested, just gave the woman her money back.

Nowadays, these courtroom shows: Divorce Court, Judge Mathis, America's Court, The Peoples Court, etc. have proliferated, and even that weird Nancy Grace has jumped on the bandwagon, so the ratings must be very good.

Not that this has improved the quality of the advertising, it's still ambulance chasing attorneys and vocational schools that 'guarantee' placement in non-existent jobs to perpetual students searching for a high-paying low effort position in the medical or criminal justice fields.

And now the viewers are invited to call in and voice their opinions about the case or various issues, and oh, by the way, receive some wonderful offers.

I used to watch those shows in the afternoon as background entertainment while I worked on needlework projects or cooked dinner. But I've been put off lately because I decided the real people who might be willing to appear on those various fake court programs have become so disgusting looking, foul mouthed, and otherwise unable to present themselves, the shows are hiring actors to portray the litigating parties in what may or may not be real life court cases.

I came to this conclusion because lately I've noticed the plaintiffs and defendants seem to be generally more attractive: well-spoken rather than profane, fit and well-groomed as opposed to being fat unkempt slobs, not obviously high on drugs or alcohol, have all their teeth, not sporting those skunk hair or neon dye jobs, and not dressing like bottom of the barrel floozies and pants-on-the-ground fools.

I think if viewers wanted to watch their ugly selves, friends, or relatives on TV in the afternoon they'd go look in the mirror or watch Jerry Springer, so the producers of these courtroom shows decided to clean it up. At first I thought the shows were recruiting a better class of litigants, but there's something fishy about it, something that doesn't quite ring true.

Here's why I think the courtroom shows use paid actors:

1. They are moderately good-looking, not movie-star quality, but character actor quality. And appropriately dressed with no body piercing or facial tattoos.

2. They tell their tale of marital or non-marital or extra-marital woe with a touch of humor and comedic timing. The stories are just a little bit too entertaining to be believable.

3. The emotional outbursts and inability to observe courtroom etiquette seem to be orchestrated for entertainment value and don't get in the way of the story or punch lines delivered by the judges.

4. The litigants are able to talk in complete sentences without profanity.

5. They show respect for the judges and are able to shut up and listen.

6. The litigants have some dignity left at the end of the case.

Take a peek at the new crop sometime and see if you agree something has changed, and these are not real people.

Me, I've been listening to BBC radio or watching Netflix online instead of turning on the television.

posted on Feb 8, 2011 10:17 AM ()

Comments:

Response to your comment -- she dozes. Or picture a cartoon where the balloon over the toon has a little black cloud in it ... that would be close.
comment by tealstar on Feb 10, 2011 7:47 AM ()
I wondered about the use of actors. I don't watch those shows anyway.
comment by solitaire on Feb 9, 2011 6:09 AM ()
I am looking forward to getting back to Colorado where I have cable TV, but from the bits I've seen while staying at the hotels here it all looks pretty bleak lately. I might have to start taking more of an interest in televised golf matches.
reply by troutbend on Feb 9, 2011 5:03 PM ()
I actually like Judy Judy....
comment by marta on Feb 8, 2011 5:50 PM ()
Her show goes back to when there weren't so many of them and has that old style look and feel.
reply by troutbend on Feb 9, 2011 5:05 PM ()
My father is a huge fan!
reply by solitaire on Feb 9, 2011 6:07 AM ()
My sister is an addict of all court shows and will watch them all day. I think there is a channel that runs one after another. I don't know how we ever got born to the same parents. I don't watch daytime TV unless there is a big event going on. We put the TV on at 5 to watch Chris Matthews.
comment by tealstar on Feb 8, 2011 3:29 PM ()
I still think of her when I grab an old envelope to use for a shopping list.
reply by troutbend on Feb 9, 2011 5:07 PM ()
I wonder what she does/thinks about during the commercials.
reply by troutbend on Feb 9, 2011 5:06 PM ()
Couldn't say, since I have never watched these shows.
comment by redimpala on Feb 8, 2011 3:01 PM ()
You quickly learn: don't put anyone on your cell phone plan and don't loan a car to your relatives. Not that you were going to do those things anyway.
reply by troutbend on Feb 9, 2011 5:04 PM ()
I know we used, to get Judge Judy, but I have to admit, never got round to watching it. I have never seen The Peoples Court advertized though. I am like you, I will listen to the radio as opposed to watching tv in the afternoon. TV companies are bound, to use actors & actresses in their shows (makes more sense).

comment by febreze on Feb 8, 2011 12:24 PM ()
I'm still listening to the Short History of Ireland in 200 Parts (or however many it is). We're up to the potato famine.
reply by troutbend on Feb 8, 2011 2:23 PM ()
I only get Judge Judy but I don't think it's fake. Many a time she has criticized the litigants for their butchery of the English language and overly casual attire. She usually give them two chances to interrupt and then they are banished from her courtroom and their suit is dismissed. I also like Judge Judy because I don't have to actually watch the TV to know what's going on which is particularly helpful while knitting intricate lace.
comment by nittineedles on Feb 8, 2011 11:48 AM ()
I haven't watched Judge Judy lately, but I agree the people who come in front of her are probably not actors. She really enjoys being able to yell at them and kick them out.
reply by troutbend on Feb 8, 2011 2:22 PM ()
I really like Judge Pierro and Divorce court, but other than that I don't need that business. Although sometimes I Do get drawn in. I have nothing to compare it to though because I have never really been home during the day before.
comment by kristilyn3 on Feb 8, 2011 11:10 AM ()
I think Divorce Court is one of the ones with actors.
reply by troutbend on Feb 8, 2011 2:24 PM ()
I haven't seen any of those shows in years. My brother (court officer) used to come down hard on them. The content was unrealistic then, so adding actors to the mix doesn't change much. And perhaps what it does change--characters speaking in complete sentences--is actually for the better.
comment by jjoohhnn on Feb 8, 2011 10:27 AM ()
I was merrily watching along, enjoying the lack of censor intervention when I realized that if it's all actors in a play, then it becomes another version of soap opera instead of a peek into the sordid affairs of real people. And any emotion or drama is just acting.That ruined it for me.
reply by troutbend on Feb 8, 2011 2:20 PM ()

Comment on this article   


1,942 articles found   [ Previous Article ]  [ Next Article ]  [ First ]  [ Last ]