Profile
Photos
Comments
Pakistan troops ordered to open fire on US raiders
Tuesday, September 16, 2008
(09-16) 14:24 PDT ISLAMABAD, Pakistan (AP) --
Pakistan's army said Tuesday that its forces have orders to open
fire if U.S. troops launch another raid across the Afghan border,
raising the stakes in a dispute over how to tackle militant havens in
Pakistan's unruly border zone.
fire if U.S. troops launch another raid across the Afghan border,
raising the stakes in a dispute over how to tackle militant havens in
Pakistan's unruly border zone.
Adm. Mike Mullen, the U.S. chairman of the joint chiefs of staff,
arrived in Pakistan late Tuesday amid the increased tensions. Mullen
planned to meet with top civilian and military leaders to discuss a
range of issues, including ways to improve coordination and cooperation
along the Pakistan-Afghan border.
arrived in Pakistan late Tuesday amid the increased tensions. Mullen
planned to meet with top civilian and military leaders to discuss a
range of issues, including ways to improve coordination and cooperation
along the Pakistan-Afghan border.
Pakistan's government has faced rising popular anger over a Sept.
3 ground attack by U.S. commandos into South Waziristan, a base for
Taliban militants killing ever more U.S. troops in Afghanistan.
Pakistan says about 15 people were killed, all of them civilians.
3 ground attack by U.S. commandos into South Waziristan, a base for
Taliban militants killing ever more U.S. troops in Afghanistan.
Pakistan says about 15 people were killed, all of them civilians.
The new firing orders were disclosed by Pakistani army spokesman
Maj. Gen. Athar Abbas in an interview Tuesday with The Associated Press.
Maj. Gen. Athar Abbas in an interview Tuesday with The Associated Press.
Abbas said Pakistani field commanders have previously been
tolerant about international forces crossing a short way into Pakistan
because of the ill-defined and contested nature of the mountainous
frontier.
tolerant about international forces crossing a short way into Pakistan
because of the ill-defined and contested nature of the mountainous
frontier.
"But after the (Sept. 3) incident, the orders are clear," Abbas
said. "In case it happens again in this form, that there is a very
significant detection, which is very definite, no ambiguity, across the
border, on ground or in the air: open fire."
said. "In case it happens again in this form, that there is a very
significant detection, which is very definite, no ambiguity, across the
border, on ground or in the air: open fire."
The statement was the strongest since Gen. Ashfaq Parvez Kayani,
Pakistan's army chief, raised eyebrows last week by vowing to defend
Pakistani territory "at all cost." Abbas would not say whether the
orders were discussed in advance with U.S. officials.
Pakistan's army chief, raised eyebrows last week by vowing to defend
Pakistani territory "at all cost." Abbas would not say whether the
orders were discussed in advance with U.S. officials.
Rep. Gary Ackerman, Democratic chair of the House of
Representatives Foreign Affairs Subcommittee on South Asia, and other
lawmakers expressed concern about Abbas' comments at a hearing Tuesday
to examine a Bush administration request to fund an upgrade of
Pakistan's aging fleet of F-16 fighter planes.
Representatives Foreign Affairs Subcommittee on South Asia, and other
lawmakers expressed concern about Abbas' comments at a hearing Tuesday
to examine a Bush administration request to fund an upgrade of
Pakistan's aging fleet of F-16 fighter planes.
Responding to the concerns, Donald Camp, deputy assistant
secretary of state for South Asian affairs, said: "I cannot envision a
situation where we would find ourselves in a shooting situation with
Pakistan."
secretary of state for South Asian affairs, said: "I cannot envision a
situation where we would find ourselves in a shooting situation with
Pakistan."
"We are partners with Pakistan. We have been close friends for years," he said.
President Asif Ali Zardari, the newly elected successor to U.S.
ally Pervez Musharraf, declined to comment on the order to use lethal
force on American troops, telling reporters in London: "I don't think
there will be any more" cross-border operations by the U.S.
ally Pervez Musharraf, declined to comment on the order to use lethal
force on American troops, telling reporters in London: "I don't think
there will be any more" cross-border operations by the U.S.
U.S. military commanders complain Islamabad has been doing too
little to prevent the Taliban and other militant groups from
recruiting, training and resupplying in Pakistan's lawless tribal belt.
little to prevent the Taliban and other militant groups from
recruiting, training and resupplying in Pakistan's lawless tribal belt.
Pakistan acknowledges the presence of al-Qaida fugitives and its
difficulties in preventing militants from seeping into Afghanistan.
However, it insists it is doing what it can and paying a heavy price,
pointing to its deployment of more then 100,000 troops in the
increasingly restive northwest and a wave of suicide bombings across
the country.
difficulties in preventing militants from seeping into Afghanistan.
However, it insists it is doing what it can and paying a heavy price,
pointing to its deployment of more then 100,000 troops in the
increasingly restive northwest and a wave of suicide bombings across
the country.
American officials have confirmed U.S. forces carried out the
Sept. 3 raid near the town of Angoor Ada in South Waziristan but have
given few details of what happened.
Sept. 3 raid near the town of Angoor Ada in South Waziristan but have
given few details of what happened.
Abbas said that Pakistan's military had asked for an explanation
but received only a half-page of "very vague" information that failed
to identify the intended target.
but received only a half-page of "very vague" information that failed
to identify the intended target.
He said the dead all appeared to be civilians, adding: "These were truck drivers, local traders and their families."
Abbas said Pakistani officials had to consider public opinion,
which is skeptical of American goals in the region and harbors sympathy
for militants fighting in the name of Islam.
which is skeptical of American goals in the region and harbors sympathy
for militants fighting in the name of Islam.
"Please look at the public reaction to this kind of adventure or
incursion," Abbas said. "The army is also an extension of the public,
and you can only satisfy the public when you match your words with your
actions."
incursion," Abbas said. "The army is also an extension of the public,
and you can only satisfy the public when you match your words with your
actions."
However, some analysts forecast that the consequences of alienating the United States would stay the army's hand.
"If an American soldier were to die because of Pakistani military
firing that would damage the Pakistani-American relationship for years
to come," said Craig Cohen, an analyst at the Center for Strategic and
International Studies in Washington.
firing that would damage the Pakistani-American relationship for years
to come," said Craig Cohen, an analyst at the Center for Strategic and
International Studies in Washington.
The threat "might stir nationalist sentiment in Pakistan and play well politically, but it's just not realistic," he said.
Pakistan's military has won American praise for a six-week
offensive against militants in the Bajur tribal region that Pakistani
officials say has killed 700 suspected insurgents and about 40 troops.
Troops backed by warplanes killed 15 more alleged militants Tuesday,
officials said.
offensive against militants in the Bajur tribal region that Pakistani
officials say has killed 700 suspected insurgents and about 40 troops.
Troops backed by warplanes killed 15 more alleged militants Tuesday,
officials said.
In the same timeframe, there has been a surge in missile strikes
apparently carried out by unmanned U.S. drones. Such attacks killed at
least two senior al-Qaida commanders earlier this year.
apparently carried out by unmanned U.S. drones. Such attacks killed at
least two senior al-Qaida commanders earlier this year.
All of those strikes have been well to the south of Bajur, in
areas where Pakistani authorities have sought peace deals in order to
gain respite from militant attacks.
areas where Pakistani authorities have sought peace deals in order to
gain respite from militant attacks.
Abbas said that while they were tackling the "mega-sanctuary" in
Bajur, they didn't have the forces to fight militants across the tribal
belt all at one time. At least two other areas have been earmarked for
military operations, he said.
Bajur, they didn't have the forces to fight militants across the tribal
belt all at one time. At least two other areas have been earmarked for
military operations, he said.
Jalaluddin Haqqani, a formidable Taliban commander whose relatives
were reportedly among the dead in one of the recent missile attacks,
was definitely in Afghanistan, he added.
were reportedly among the dead in one of the recent missile attacks,
was definitely in Afghanistan, he added.
Abbas denied the new order had been put into practice before dawn
on Monday, when U.S. helicopters reportedly landed near Angoor Ada only
to fly away after troops fired warning shots.
on Monday, when U.S. helicopters reportedly landed near Angoor Ada only
to fly away after troops fired warning shots.
Abbas insisted no foreign troops had crossed the border and that
"trigger-happy tribesmen" fired the shots. Pakistani troops based
nearby fired flares to see what was going on, he said.
"trigger-happy tribesmen" fired the shots. Pakistani troops based
nearby fired flares to see what was going on, he said.
The U.S. military in Afghanistan said none of its troops were involved.
___
Associated Press writers Nahal Toosi in Islamabad, Habib Khan in Khar, and David Stringer in London contributed to this report.